Costs of production and dissemination
The cost effectiveness of having information in hypertext form should be
considered. Conventional IR systems allow only retrieval while hypertext
systems help users integrate units of information retrieved.
Evaluation should also include looking for the availability of automated tools
or cognitive prostheses to overcome cognitive overhead and disorientation.
Readers adapt different navigation strategies based on the complexity of the
task at hand. Such tools might help with a variety of subtasks related to
hypertext usage. These subtasks might include specifying search targets and
planning the order in which information will be sought. Tools are also
required to store and manipulate the information found in order to integrate
with other work. However, the effectiveness of such tools might be reduced due
to the following:
- Readers may not realize they need help.
- Readers may not know how to use such tools.
- Readers might blindly follow certain procedures without understanding their need.
Hence, the design and evaluation of hypertext systems should include the
understanding of how people use their cognitive resources to handle
information.
Nielsen also has discussed four categories for the evaluation of hypertext
documents.[Nielsen, 1991]
These are:
- Utility
This is a measure of whether the hypertext document actually helps a user
perform the intended task. This has to be compared with performing the same
tasks with linear text. Many empirical tests have shown that readers exhibit
poorer performance with hypertext than with paper documents.
- Integrity
This is a measure of the completeness of the document - whether it is up to
date and not misleading and if it is easy to maintain.
- Usability
Usability can be measured as a combination of these factors:
- Ease of learning - It is a measure of how fast a reader can start
learning and navigating through a hypertext document. Good presentation
structure and graphic design are key determinants.
- Ease of use - It is a measure of how fast a reader can locate
information. Appropriately defined links, search mechanisms, backtracks,
landmarks and other navigational aids can greatly increase efficiency of use.
- Error handling - It is a measure of how many errors a reader makes and
how easy it is for them to recover from such errors.
- Aesthetics
This is a measure of how pleasing is the system to the user.
|